Strang Scott has previously written about both the Wage Act, the Massachusetts law protecting the earnings of workers, as well as the independent contractor statute, which governs the classification of workers as either employees or independent contractors. Violating the Wage Act and independent contractor statute can have significant real-world consequences. One consequence is a state investigation of wage theft. “Wage theft” is a broad term signifying an employer’s illegal retention of earned wages. The Boston Globe recently reported that “wage theft” is rampant throughout the construction industry. Wage theft often incurs in conjunction with the misclassification of workers as independent contractors, particularly at the subcontractor level where many workers are paid in cash. According to the Globe, the Massachusetts attorney general’s office has issued 253 wage-related citations to the construction industry alone over the last eighteen months, totaling more than $1.6 million in penalties and unpaid wages. The Attorney General’s office views investigating and prosecuting wage theft as a priority.
Employers who commit wage theft or misclassify their workers do so at substantial risk. Any worker is free to file a complaint with the Attorney General’s office, which will conduct a preliminary investigation or allow the worker to file a private law suit. Should the Attorney General ultimately find that a violation occurred, penalties start at $10,000 for non-willful violations, and $25,000 for willful violations. Repeat violations incur higher penalties, and willful violations may be further punished by debarment, preventing offending companies from seeking public contracts.
Current Massachusetts law holds the employer and the employer’s owners and/or managers liable for wage-related violations, but the legislature is considering expanding on current law. State Senator Sal DiDomenico has filed a bill to address the wage theft problem. Among other provisions, the bill (currently known as S.966) will hold “lead companies” responsible for wage violations. “Lead companies” are defined as any business entity that obtains or is provided workers directly from a labor contractor or indirectly from a subcontractor. In other words, should this bill become law, first tier subcontractors and general contractors would share liability for wage issues, include wage theft and independent contractor misclassification. Opponents of the bill have highlighted the potentially unfair burden the legislation would place on honest general contractors, and it is unknown if the bill will ultimately become law. However, all employers (particularly subcontractors, general contractors, and other entities operating in the construction industry) should properly classify all of their existing workers and be advised that the legislature may increase their direct liability for unpaid wages and misclassified workers. Employers should consult with their counsel to ensure that all workers are properly paid and classified.
